Skip to content
The Cyano Codex
Choose language

Safety in cyanotype toning and variants: other chemicals

Cyanotype variants and toning use other chemicals, and each comes with its own risk and its own safety data sheet. New Cyanotype is harmful if swallowed and through the skin, its original formula contains dichromate, and some old toners use lead or nickel. Here is what is known about each one and what we don’t publish.
Section
Safety
Reviewed
Reading time
13 min
Sources
24

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How we fund the site

Tray with closed bottles of different kinds, nitrile gloves and safety glasses
Plate 1Other chemicals, the same caution.

In short

  • The ferric ammonium oxalate in New Cyanotype is harmful if swallowed and in contact with skin.
  • Ammonium dichromate is carcinogenic under the REACH regulation: we don’t publish the recipe that contains it.
  • New Cyanotype crystals go to the hazardous waste drop-off: Ware says they can go down the drain, but the oxalate data sheet forbids it.
  • The sodium carbonate in bleaching baths irritates the eyes and reacts strongly with acids.
  • We don’t give recipes for toners with lead or nickel.
  • Before opening a new product, read its safety data sheet.
On this page (8 sections)
  1. What changes when the formula isn’t the classic one?
  2. New Cyanotype: oxalate and dichromate
  3. New Cyanotype crystals
  4. Simple Cyanotype: what we know and what we don’t
  5. Development acids: nitric, citric and vinegar
  6. Bleaching and toning
  7. Heavy metal toners: why we don’t recommend them
  8. How to work with a chemical you don’t know

What changes when the formula isn’t the classic one?#

When the formula isn’t the classic one, the chemicals change, and so do the risks. Mike Ware’s New Cyanotype replaces the citrate with ferric ammonium oxalate, harmful if swallowed and in contact with skin1, and toners add alkalis, acids or tannins. Every product calls for reading its data sheet before you open it.

The precautions for classic cyanotype are in the cyanotype safety guide; this page brings together what changes with other chemicals. Toning changes the blue tone of the print with a bath, and bleaching is the preliminary step that lightens or removes the blue, usually with an alkali2. The techniques, with their results, are in cyanotype toning.

Mike Ware, creator of New Cyanotype and Simple Cyanotype, sums it up in the general warning on his website: some of the products in his processes are moderately toxic, and all should be considered potentially harmful3. This table sets out what we know about each variant and what we don’t:

What changes when the formula isn’t the classic one?
Formula or bath Chemical that changes What we know about its safety Source
New Cyanotype (Ware, 1995) Ferric ammonium oxalate and, in the original formula, ammonium dichromate Oxalate: harmful if swallowed and through the skin. Dichromate: carcinogenic, mutagenic and toxic to reproduction 1,4
Simple Cyanotype (Ware) Iron(III) nitrate, citric acid and ammonia Ware considers it fairly low in toxicity; the data sheets classify 25% ammonia as corrosive and the nitrate as an oxidizer and irritant or corrosive, depending on the manufacturer 5,6,7
Acid development Nitric, hydrochloric, sulfamic or citric acid, highly diluted Depends on the acid: see its section 8
Bleaching Sodium carbonate or ammonia Carbonate: irritates the eyes and reacts strongly with acids; 25% ammonia: corrosive and a respiratory irritant, no data sheet consulted for the diluted bath 9,6
Toning Tea, coffee, tannic acid or gallic acid Data sheets not consulted 2
Old toners Lead acetate, nickel salts and others We don’t recommend them 10

New Cyanotype: oxalate and dichromate#

New Cyanotype, the variant Mike Ware introduced in 199510, is more toxic than classic cyanotype. Its ferric ammonium oxalate is classified as harmful if swallowed and in contact with skin1. Ware himself warns that his sensitizer is toxic if swallowed, more so than the traditional one8.

Sigma-Aldrich gives the oxalate the same classification, with the exclamation mark pictogram and the signal word “Warning”11. Ware adds that his sensitizer stains skin, wood, clothing, textiles and any absorbent surface8. The Thermo Fisher data sheet says to keep it away from humid air and direct sunlight, and lists it as incompatible with oxidizers and strong acids1. It also treats it as hazardous waste that must not go down the drain.

Given these data, New Cyanotype calls for a little more than the classic formula:

A commercial mix of this type, Fotospeed’s Cyanotype Sensitiser, shows how all of this translates to a label. Its data sheet is internally inconsistent, so we use it only as an illustration13:

New Cyanotype: oxalate and dichromate
What the data sheet declares Fact Source
Ferric ammonium oxalate Less than 30% of the mix 13
Potassium ferricyanide Less than 10% 13
Ammonium dichromate Less than 0.1% 13
Classification of the mix Harmful if swallowed (H302), with the acid warning (EUH032) 13
What to avoid Acids, temperatures above 50 °C and direct sunlight 13

Dichromate is out#

The original New Cyanotype formula contains a small amount of ammonium dichromate8. It is a substance that Annex XIV of the European REACH regulation lists among those that are carcinogenic, mutagenic and toxic to reproduction, and its use in the European Union has required authorization since September 20174. Ware himself writes that it introduces a very toxic substance, albeit in a very small amount, that is now banned in many countries5.

That’s why we don’t publish the recipe with dichromate. Ware notes in his workshop notes that it can be left out, at the cost of lower contrast and a shorter sensitizer shelf life10: with dichromate it lasts from one to several years, depending on which of Ware’s texts you consult10,8, and without it that can drop to a few months5. The dichromate-free version is explained in Ware’s New Cyanotype.

Dichromate also appears in some old washing recipes: the National Science and Media Museum blog mentions a few drops of it in the water to boost contrast14. We don’t recommend it for that use either.

New Cyanotype crystals#

When New Cyanotype is prepared, about 15 g of potassium ferric oxalate crystallizes out and is separated by filtering10. Sources disagree on what to do with these crystals, so we take the cautious approach: a closed, labeled jar, and off to the hazardous waste drop-off.

What you’ll hear and what the sources say
What you’ll hear What the sources say Source
Wash the crystals down the drain with hot water This is what Ware suggests in his workshop notes 10
Oxalate residues can be poured away The data sheet for ferric ammonium oxalate, the starting chemical, says not to empty it into drains and to treat it as hazardous waste 1

The crystals are a different compound, potassium ferric oxalate, and we haven’t been able to consult its data sheet. Until we have it, we follow the one for the chemical they come from. All other waste, from the first bath to the containers, is covered in how to dispose of cyanotype waste.

Simple Cyanotype: what we know and what we don’t#

Simple Cyanotype is another of Mike Ware’s formulas, with no dichromate or oxalate, which its creator describes as fairly low in toxicity and not harmful to the environment5. That is Ware’s assessment, not a safety data sheet’s, and its starting chemicals include iron(III) nitrate and ammonia15.

The data sheets for those chemicals call for more care than that assessment suggests. The one for 25% ammonia solution classifies it as corrosive to skin and eyes, a respiratory irritant and very toxic to aquatic life6. The one for iron(III) nitrate varies between manufacturers: an oxidizer and irritant according to PanReac, corrosive according to Labbox7,16.

In practice: goggles, gloves, working outdoors or by an open window when measuring the ammonia, and each chemical stored separately, because the ammonia data sheet lists it as incompatible with nitrates6. The formula, the preparation and all its precautions are in Mike Ware’s Simple Cyanotype.

Development acids: nitric, citric and vinegar#

Some formulas are developed in a highly diluted acid bath. Ware recommends nitric acid at around 1%, or hydrochloric or sulfamic acid at 1%, or citric acid at 1–2%8. With ferricyanide, the rule is always the same: the acid goes into the bath water, never into the powders or the solution.

Development acids: nitric, citric and vinegar
Acidic Bath concentration according to Ware What its data sheet or source says Source
Nitric Around 1% Concentrated, it is corrosive and gives off fumes; Ware first makes a 10% stock solution and considers the final bath not hazardous 10
Hydrochloric or sulfamic 1 % We haven’t consulted their data sheets 8
Citric 1-2 % Irritates the eyes and, as a powder, the respiratory tract; incompatible with oxidizers, reducing agents and alkalis 17
Acetic (vinegar) Ware advises against it for New Cyanotype10 Irritates skin and eyes from 10% and is corrosive from 25% 18

That the final nitric bath isn’t hazardous is Ware’s opinion, not a safety data sheet’s10. Since the concentrated acid is corrosive and gives off fumes, we don’t recommend nitric acid for working at home. Citric acid, on the other hand, comes as a powder: dissolve it in the bath water and don’t store or weigh it next to the ferricyanide.

For the substitutes for nitric acid, Ware’s two texts disagree: his 2009 workshop notes give sulfamic at 5–10% and citric at 1–5%10, and his website, sulfamic at 1% and citric at 1–2%8. Here we follow the website figures, which are the lower ones. Ware adds a preservation warning: citric acid, if not rinsed out well, can leave the print more prone to fading8.

Bleaching and toning#

Bleaching and toning change the blue of the print with baths of other products, and each one calls for its data sheet. The sodium carbonate in many bleaches irritates the eyes and reacts strongly with acids, giving off heat9: wear eye protection, and rinse the tray before moving on to an acid bath.

Bleaching works because the alkali breaks Prussian blue down into hydrated iron oxide, which is yellowish19, and leaves ferrocyanide ions in the water19. That’s why the bleach bath is disposed of like the first wash bath, although the carbonate data sheets disagree on its disposal: Jacquard allows small amounts to be diluted with plenty of water, and Th. Geyer says it must not reach the sewer20,9.

Classic toning to black or brown first bleaches with ammonia and then stains with tannic or gallic acid2; the National Science and Media Museum blog gives recipes with ammonium hydroxide14. Borax is also used, giving a violet tinge14, as are household drinks such as tea or coffee, which shift the print toward sepia tones21. These are the products used in toning and washing, with what we know about their safety:

Bleaching and toning
Product What it’s used for What its safety data sheet says Source
Sodium carbonate Bleaching Eye irritant (H319); strong exothermic reaction with acids 9,20
3% hydrogen peroxide Speeding up the appearance of the blue in the wash Its data sheet labels it an eye irritant; from 8% it can cause serious eye damage 22
Polysorbate 20 (Tween 20) Wetting agent for the solution Not classified as hazardous 23
Ammonia Bleaching At 25%, corrosive (H314), a respiratory irritant (H335) and very toxic to aquatic life (H400); for the diluted bath, read the data sheet for the product you use 6
Tannic acid, gallic acid, borax Toning We haven’t consulted their data sheets: read them before opening the product —
Tea and coffee Toning to sepia tones They’re food, but the bath has been in contact with the print 21

With hydrogen peroxide, remember that the data sheets list ferricyanide as incompatible with strong oxidizers24: it only goes into the bath, diluted, never into the powders or the solution. And with tea or coffee, the rule is the same as for any bath in the studio: a dedicated tray, gloves, no drinking it and, when you’re done, into the waste bottle with the first wash bath. How each bleach is done is covered in cyanotype bleaching.

Hands in nitrile gloves lift a cyanotype toned to warm tones out of a tray of tea, next to a pitcher of tea
Plate 2Each bath in its own tray and with gloves: the tea toner comes from the kitchen, but the water that comes out of it no longer belongs there.

Heavy metal toners: why we don’t recommend them#

Toners with lead acetate or nickel salts exist and have been used, but we don’t recommend them or give their recipes. Mike Ware describes lead acetate as a seriously toxic heavy metal salt, and nickel salts as recognized carcinogens10. Their technical advantages don’t make up for that risk in a studio.

Those advantages are real. Lead toning gives a violet tone and makes the print roughly four times more resistant to light19. Ware rules it out because of the strong color shift and the toxicity of the bath. Nickel salts increase resistance to alkalis, at the cost of a greenish blue and less density in the midtones19.

In the 19th and early 20th centuries, cyanotypes were toned with other chemicals: green with acidified iron(II) sulfate, bluish lilac with potassium sulfocyanide, violet with lead acetate or warm black with silver2. We mention them as history, not as recipes. The National Science and Media Museum blog also warns that the sulfuric acid in some green toners can release hydrogen cyanide gas with cyanotype chemistry14.

How to work with a chemical you don’t know#

Before opening a chemical you don’t know, find the safety data sheet from the manufacturer of the container you have and read its hazards, how to handle and store it, and what protection it calls for. If you can’t find the data sheet, or the label doesn’t say what’s in the product, don’t use it.

How to find what matters is explained in how to read a safety data sheet. With any new product, these habits also apply; they come from the data sheets we have consulted:

Frequently asked questions

Can I make New Cyanotype without dichromate?

Yes. Ware notes in his workshop notes that the dichromate can be left out, although contrast and sensitizer shelf life go down: without it, the solution may last only a few months. That’s the version we explain, because dichromate is a carcinogenic, mutagenic substance that is toxic to reproduction under the European REACH regulation.

Is it safe to tone a cyanotype with tea?

We haven’t found a data sheet or a safety source on tea or coffee toning baths. Tea and coffee come from the kitchen, but the bath has been in contact with the print: use it in a tray set aside for the studio, with gloves, don’t drink it, and treat it like the first wash bath when you dispose of it.

Why shouldn’t the carbonate bath be mixed with the acid bath?

Because sodium carbonate reacts strongly with acids and gives off heat, according to its safety data sheet. Rinse the tray with water between one bath and the next, or use a separate tray for each, and don’t pour the two leftovers into the same container when you collect them for the hazardous waste drop-off.

What do I do with the green crystals that form when preparing New Cyanotype?

Store them in a closed, labeled jar and take them to the hazardous waste drop-off. Sources disagree: Ware suggests washing them away with hot tap water, but the data sheet for the ferric ammonium oxalate they come from says not to pour it down the drain. Since the crystals are a different compound whose data sheet we haven’t been able to consult, we follow the cautious approach.

Your next step

Tone the blue of your cyanotypeWhat cyanotype toning is, how the classic bleach-and-tannin method works, what tones each bath gives, and what is known about tea and safety.

Sources

  1. Thermo Fisher Scientific. (2025). Safety data sheet: Ammonium iron(III) oxalate trihydrate, 98% (revision 4, ref. 11449377). https://www.fishersci.ie/store/msds?partNumber=11449377&productDescription%3DAMMONIUM+IRON%28III%29+OXALATETRIHYDRATE%2C+98%25%2C100G&countryCode=IE&language=en. Accessed October 16, 2026. 123456
  2. Stulik, D. C. and Kaplan, A. (2013). Cyanotype. In The atlas of analytical signatures of photographic processes. Getty Conservation Institute. https://www.getty.edu/conservation/publications_resources/pdf_publications/pdf/atlas_cyanotype.pdf 1234
  3. Ware, M. (n.d.). Warning & disclaimer. Mike Ware: Alternative photography. https://www.mikeware.co.uk/mikeware/warning.html Accessed October 16, 2026.
  4. European Commission. (2013). Commission Regulation (EU) No 348/2013 of 17 April 2013 amending Annex XIV to Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006 (REACH). https://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2013/348/data.html Accessed October 16, 2026. 12
  5. Ware, M. (n.d.). Towards an unproblematic cyanotype chemistry. Mike Ware: Alternative photography. https://mikeware.co.uk/mikeware/tocyan.html Accessed October 16, 2026. 1234
  6. Panreac Química S.L.U. (2025). Ficha de datos de seguridad: Amoníaco en solución 25 % (version 14.12, item 1129). https://www.itwreagents.com/download_file/sds/141129/es/sds_141129_es.pdf. Accessed October 17, 2026. 12345
  7. Panreac Química S.L.U. (2025). Fiche de données de sécurité: Iron(III) Nitrate 9-hydrate [Safety data sheet, in French] (version 7.04, item 1297). https://www.itwreagents.com/download_file/sds/141297/fr/sds_141297_fr.pdf. Accessed October 17, 2026. 12
  8. Ware, M. (n.d.). The New Cyanotype process. Mike Ware: Alternative photography. https://www.mikeware.co.uk/mikeware/New_Cyanotype_Process.html Accessed October 16, 2026. 12345678910
  9. Th. Geyer GmbH & Co. KG. (2022). Safety data sheet: Sodium carbonate (version 4, item 1393). https://pdf.dutscher.com/doc/1393-1KG-KIS/1393-1KG-KIS_FDS.pdf. Accessed October 16, 2026. 12345
  10. Ware, M. (2009). New Cyanotype: Siderotype workshop notes. https://www.mikeware.co.uk/downloads/CyanoWork.pdf Accessed October 17, 2026. 1234567891011
  11. Sigma-Aldrich. (n.d.). Ammonium iron(III) oxalate trihydrate (ref. 12302) [Product page]. https://perfqws.sigmaaldrich.com/CA/en/product/sial/12302. Accessed October 16, 2026.
  12. Honeywell Specialty Chemicals Seelze GmbH. (2025). Safety data sheet: Potassium hexacyanoferrate(III) (version 2.4, ref. 31253). https://pdf.dutscher.com/doc/31253-1KG-HON/31253-1KG-HON_FDSen.pdf. Accessed October 16, 2026. 12
  13. Jay House Ltd. (2017). Safety data sheet: Cyanotype Sensitiser (version 2, Fotospeed brand). https://www.freestylephoto.com/static/pdf/msds/fotospeed/308510_SDS.pdf. Accessed October 16, 2026. 123456
  14. National Science and Media Museum. (2011, February 18). Introduction to the cyanotype process. National Science and Media Museum Blog. https://blog.scienceandmediamuseum.org.uk/introduction-cyanotype-process/ Accessed October 17, 2026. 1234
  15. Ware, M. (2022). Alternative photographic processes: Simple Cyanotype [PDF instructions]. https://mikeware.co.uk/downloads/SimpleCy22.pdf Accessed October 16, 2026.
  16. Labbox Labware S.L. (2026). Ficha de datos de seguridad: Hierro (III) nitrato nonahidrato Analytical Grade ACS (version 1.4, ref. IRNA-09A). https://labbox.es/wp-content/uploads/FDS/SDS_ES_10274.pdf. Accessed October 17, 2026.
  17. Panreac Química S.L.U. (2025). Safety data sheet: Citric acid (version 9.04, item 1808). https://deca.upc.edu/en/laboratories/latem/security/reactius-quimics/anhydrous-citric-acid-panreac.pdf. Accessed October 16, 2026.
  18. Panreac Química S.L.U. (2025). Safety data sheet: Acetic acid glacial (version 10.05, art. 1008). https://deca.upc.edu/en/laboratories/latem/security/reactius-quimics/acetic-acid-panreac.pdf. Accessed October 16, 2026.
  19. Ware, M. (2003). A blueprint for conserving cyanotypes. Topics in Photographic Preservation, 10, 2-18. https://resources.culturalheritage.org/pmgtopics/2003-volume-ten/10_02_Ware.pdf 1234
  20. Rupert, Gibbon & Spider, Inc. (2018). Safety data sheet: Soda ash (sodium carbonate) [component of the Procion MX dye 4 color set]. https://www.jerrysartarama.com/media/pdfs/jacquard/procion-dye-4-color-set-soda-ash-SDS-2021.pdf. Accessed October 16, 2026. 12
  21. Jacquard Products. (2019). Cyanotype FAQs [Manufacturer’s document, version 02.08.19]. https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/2714/2506/files/Cyanotype-FAQs.pdf Accessed October 17, 2026. 12
  22. Chemos GmbH & Co. KG. (2024). Safety data sheet: Hydrogen peroxide solution 3% (version GHS 1.0, item A0272345). https://www.chemos.de/import/data/msds/GB_en/7722-84-1-A0272345-GB-en.pdf. Accessed October 16, 2026.
  23. AppliChem GmbH. (2025). Safety data sheet: Polysorbate 20 (version 6.14, art. A4974). https://pdf.dutscher.com/doc/348637/348637_FDSen.pdf. Accessed October 16, 2026.
  24. Thermo Fisher (Kandel) GmbH. (2025). Safety data sheet: Potassium hexacyanoferrate(III) (revision 5, ref. A16946). https://deca.upc.edu/en/laboratories/latem/security/reactius-quimics/potassium-hexacyanoferrate-iii-fisher-scientific.pdf. Accessed October 16, 2026.

Reviewed on October 16, 2026. If you spot an error or a missing source, write to us and we’ll look into it.

How to cite this page

The Cyano Codex. (2026, October 16). Safety in cyanotype toning and variants: other chemicals. https://cyanocodex.com/en/safety/toning-and-other-formulas/